I originally signed up for Catholic Match because of a joke. Seriously, I did! A coworker left an article on my desk at work, clipped from the local newspaper. It was all about the percentage of men vs. women on various dating websites. The site that the article said had the most women was a website I had never heard of—CatholicMatch.com.
My coworker thought it was hysterical. He already knew I was Catholic. So he said that if I couldn't find a good Catholic girl on a site with odds this good, I might as well give up! Oh yeah, it was hysterical all right... ;)
I wasn't even thinking about dating at the time. I was discouraged by the prospects of finding a Catholic woman, who also shared my values, and whose personality was also compatible with mine. Plus, I had a tiny little problem—I was still discerning whether or not God was calling me to the priesthood.
But the article intrigued me. I had to sign up, just to see if the type of woman I was discouraged about finding could actually be waiting for me on this Catholic-focused site.
Then, I realized I had to fill out a profile and actually try to describe myself! As many other people on Catholic Match (CM) have discovered, this is not easy. I put off completing my profile for months. And when I finally did fill out my profile, I had to get over that fear we all have of communicating with someone you don't know. I was an active member of CM, but had yet to come out of my shell and really use the site to its full potential (or any potential really, for that matter!).
As I went through this process, Lisa also became active on CM. She had a totally different path from me. She had just gone on a string of disappointing (OK, actually, closer to horrendous) dates that had left her discouraged as well. As she searched for Catholic dating websites, she came across CM and decided to sign up. To her surprise, the e-mail address she entered indicated that she was already a member! She had signed up many years before when the site was still called StRaphael.net. So, she had a low member number that made it look like she had been there for years, even though she wasn't. It did make her stand out, though...
But unlike me, she came on to CM to actively look for her future spouse. And so she immediately got involved with the Forums. She made several good friends during this time, and this led to her famous “crush” threads (as in...”tell everyone who you have a crush on”). And of course, her Forum activity ultimately gave her the idea to start her own advice thread. And soon, “Ask Lisa.” was born!
In the meantime, still firmly in my shell, I heavily lurked in the Forums. I noticed Lisa right away. That low member number was what caught my eye at first. But then, I noticed much more. Not only was this woman amazingly cute, but she also had a lot of really great things to say in her posts. Her humorous posts were really funny. Her serious posts were faith-filled and profound. And her advice was incredibly wise, well beyond her years (as all Ask Lisa fans already know!).
And to top it all off, based on what she wrote, I saw that she is a kind, sweet, and family-oriented woman. She even worked for her church! And I found myself agreeing with just about everything she posted. No matter what the topic, she said just what I would've said...if I had had the courage to post it myself! ;)
I started to go into threads that I thought she would like, just to see if she had posted. Then...I gave up all pretenses and just started directly searching for her posts! And through it all, I started to wonder...is it possible that this girl could actually meet all those criteria that I never thought I could find in a woman? But then, I came to my senses (or so I thought at the time) and said this was crazy. She is a Canadian, and I'm 1000 miles away in a whole other country! I put the thought out of my mind...for a while. Plus, I still wasn't sure if God was even calling me to marriage at all.
But, I had to do something to lead me closer to a decision. So after being on CM for over a year with nothing to show but a handful of posts and a few unanswered emotes, I decided that I needed to get serious about the site. So in late 2009, I started making a conscious effort to make connections on the site. And I said a prayer that is now famous to me and Lisa...”God, make Your Will known to me through my being active on this website.”
And with that, I started connecting with women in earnest. I even went out on a few dates! A whole new world of possibilities opened up to me when I realized I could actually get a hang of this whole online dating thing!
While I was finally getting the hang of CM, Lisa was getting frustrated. She was convinced that there would be a plethora of men in her area on the site. She had read success stories where couples lived far away from each other, but she was unwilling to expand her search criteria that far. Then, on a retreat, she brought the whole situation before God. And she was surprised to her God's answer very clearly: she needed to be open to being led “where you do not want to go” (Jn 21:18). And so, she immediately returned home and changed her profile to read, “Open to living anywhere”.
And...it didn't hurt that she changed one other thing....her profile picture! Now, before you think I'm just being shallow, keep in mind that Lisa had thought about changing her picture for a while and finally decided on a recent photo that she really liked (yes...it apparently was a “good hair day”). She showed the picture to one of her good CM friends, who told her, “This picture will land you a husband someday!”. And when I saw this picture, it was instantly my favorite of all the pictures I had ever seen her post! This woman was not just cute, but outright gorgeous!
And so, fresh off my newfound success with CM, I got just enough courage to write to her. But I seriously thought I was just writing her to “get it out of my system.” You see, she was so popular around the Forums that I was convinced she was already communicating with someone. I thought I would write to her, maybe we would exchange a few polite e-mails, and that was it. But—just in case—I pulled out my “A-game” and wrote her a message (not just a brief “wink”) that is famous to this day for its wit and charm (in my mind anyway). I wrote her a note about her famous glasses, and how they were by far the best part of her profile (which was just a joke—I also listed all the great qualities I noticed in her posts).
I read and re-read the note to proofread it. Then I asked myself one last time if I was sure about this. But before I could even think, I found myself pressing the “send” button....
So will I like his note as much he did? Will I write back? Be sure to check out part 2 coming soon!